Finding thoughtful holiday gifts can be tricky, especially when you’re shopping for the loved ones who reappear on your list every year. To help, we’ve curated a mix of gifts that are affordable, flexible, sometimes edible, and best of all, local. Every product is sourced from a maker in our home county of Lancaster, PA, because we believe supporting local businesses is always a thoughtful way to give.
Below, you’ll find everything from hand-poured candles to screen-printed market totes, along with a few favorites from Wilbur Chocolate. Mix and match to make your own themed gift basket or handpick the individual products that spark cheer. We hope these ideas enliven your holiday gifting!
Sweet Mornings, Happy Evenings
- Wilbur Mixed Milk & Semisweet Chocolate Buds ($9.50)
- Tree Mug by One Table Project ($41)
- Granola by Thom’s Bread ($10) – purchase at a Thom’s location
- Wilbur Antique Cocoa Tin filled with 14 oz. Dutch Processed Cocoa Powder ($13.50)
- Tea Samplers by Lancaster Farmacy ($14)
- 3 Amigos Central American Blend Coffee by Whiff Roasters ($14.95)
Stocking Stuffers
- Fig & Rhubarb Candle by Hamilton Wax Co. ($13.99)
- Lancaster PA Sticker Pack by MichaelaJoCreative on Etsy ($12)
- Wilbur Bud-E-Bear ($12.99)
- Locally Printed T-Shirt by Foxduck ($30)
- Wilbur Holiday Mug O'Buds filled with 8 oz. Mixed Wilbur Buds ($15.99)
- Lancaster Central Market Bag by Paper Jane Studio ($15) – purchase at market
- Wilbur Bud Key Ring ($4.99)
Sweet & Salty
- Large Decorative Tin of Horse & Buggy Pretzels by Tom Sturgis ($39.50)
- Wilbur Triple Coated Almonds 1 lb. Box ($14.99)
- Gift Pack of Stroopwafels by Stroopies (from $9)
- Lemon Creamed Honey by Heirloom Acre Honey ($11)
- Salted Dark Chocolate Caramel Corn by Emma’s Gourmet Popcorn (from $4.05)
- Wilbur Lititz Sweet & Salty Bark – 12 oz. Bag ($12.50)